Government grants are one of the biggest incentives to making contributions into a Registered Disability Savings Plan (RDSP). Depending on family income, the government may deposit as much as $3 for every $1 contributed, subject to annual and lifetime limits. However, the maximum lifetime grant limit is $70,000, and eligibility ends after the year in which the beneficiary turns 49. So, is it still worth contributing to an RDSP once government grants are no longer available?
The answer depends on the beneficiary’s circumstances. Although additional RDSP contributions become less appealing once government grants are no longer available, they may still provide important benefits in certain situations.
Does an unmatched RDSP contribution provide any benefit?
Investments held within the RDSP can grow tax sheltered while the money remains in the plan. When money is eventually withdrawn, the portion representing contributions is tax free, while the portions representing government grants and bonds, investment growth, and eligible rollovers are included in the beneficiary’s taxable income. Secondly, assets held inside an RDSP are exempt when determining eligibility for provincial or territorial disability support programs. This can make the RDSP invaluable for someone who has to respect asset limits to continue receiving disability benefits.
An unmatched RDSP contribution can therefore continue to provide tax sheltered investment growth and protection from provincial or territorial disability assistance asset limits. Whether those advantages justify making additional contributions after government grants are no longer available may depend on what other investment options are available.
RDSP vs TFSA
If the beneficiary has unused contribution room, the TFSA may be the more optimal account for savings, particularly if provincial disability asset limits are not a concern. TFSA withdrawals are completely tax free, including any investment growth earned within the account. In contrast, investment growth inside an RDSP is sheltered while inside the plan, but fully taxable to the beneficiary’s when withdrawn.
A TFSA is also more flexible. Money can be withdrawn whenever it is needed, and the amount withdrawn is added back to the TFSA contribution room in the following calendar year. Conversely, RDSP withdrawals are subject to complex rules and restrictions. Depending on the beneficiary’s age and the government grants or bonds received inside the RDSP, a withdrawal may trigger repayment of grants or bonds under the proportional repayment rule or be subject to annual withdrawal limits. Unlike a TFSA, withdrawing money from an RDSP does not restore contribution room. RDSP contributions continue to count toward the $200,000 lifetime limit even after they have been withdrawn, and any government grants or bonds repaid as a result of an early withdrawal because of the proportional repayment rule are lost forever.
For someone receiving provincial or territorial disability income supports, remaining below the applicable asset limit can be imperative to retaining eligibility. While assets held inside an RDSP are exempt from provincial and territorial disability assistance asset limits, a TFSA does count toward the limit and may affect eligibility for benefits.
RDSP vs RRSP
An RRSP contribution qualifies for an income tax deduction, whereas contributions to an RDSP or TFSA do not. The value of the RRSP deduction depends on the individual’s marginal tax rate. Someone with a relatively high income today who expects to have a lower income in retirement may receive substantial value from the RRSP deduction. Conversely, someone with very little taxable income may receive considerably less value, if any value at all, from making an RRSP contribution.
Both the RDSP and RRSP shelter investment growth while money remains inside the plan, but their taxation upon withdrawal is different. An RRSP withdrawal counts as fully taxable income. With an RDSP, the portion representing contributions is received tax free, while the portion representing government grants and bonds, investment growth and eligible rollovers is taxable when withdrawn.
Provincial and territorial disability assistance rules must also be considered. Unlike an RDSP which is an exempt asset, RRSPs may count toward applicable asset limits depending on the province or territory; However, there are partial exemptions in Quebec, New Brunswick and Nova Scotia as of 2026. Having non exempt assets that exceed applicable limits can affect an individual’s eligibility for disability support programs.
RDSP vs FHSA
A First Home Savings Account (FHSA) may be a suitable account type for a beneficiary who qualifies as a first time home buyer and intends to purchase a home. FHSA contributions are tax deductible and withdrawals used to purchase a first home are tax free. The FHSA combines the tax deductible contributions of an RRSP with the tax free withdrawals of a TFSA. For someone planning to purchase a first home, an FHSA may offer greater tax advantages than making additional unmatched RDSP contributions. Unlike an RDSP, an FHSA is not exempt from provincial or territorial disability assistance asset limits and may affect eligibility for benefits.
RDSP vs RESP
A Registered Education Savings Plan (RESP) is designed to help families save for a beneficiary’s post-secondary education. Like an RDSP, contributions are not tax deductible, but investment growth is tax sheltered while the money remains in the plan. An RESP may also qualify for government grants and bonds, subject to eligibility requirements.
For families saving for a child’s post-secondary education, an RESP may offer greater benefits than making additional unmatched RDSP contributions, particularly while grants and bonds are available. Both RDSPs and RESPs are considered exempt assets in all 13 provinces and territories when determining eligibility for disability supports.
RDSP vs non-registered account
An unmatched RDSP contribution can become more interesting once available TFSA or RRSP room has been exhausted. Investments held in a non-registered account do not benefit from tax sheltered growth and may generate taxable income as it is earned. Interest is taxable annually, while dividends and realized capital gains will also result in tax liabilities. Inside an RDSP, investment growth can accumulate without annual taxation while the money remains in the plan. However, investments held in a non-registered account may benefit from preferential tax treatment, particularly in the case of eligible Canadian dividends and capital gains.
As with RRSPs and TFSAs, non-registered investments may count toward provincial or territorial disability assistance asset limits and potentially affect eligibility for benefits.
Unlocking non-PGAP status
An RDSP becomes a Primarily Government Assisted Plan (PGAP) at the beginning of a calendar year if the total government grants and bonds paid into the plan exceed total private contributions. Conversely, the RDSP becomes a non-PGAP if private contributions are greater than or equal to government grants and bonds. PGAPs are subject to a combined annual withdrawal limit, while non-PGAPs are not subject to the same limit. Making additional contributions that do not trigger government grants may help change an RDSP from PGAP to non-PGAP and provide greater flexibility when withdrawing funds. Whether this strategy makes financial sense depends on the amount of additional contributions required.
What’s the verdict?
Once government grants are no longer available, the RDSP must be compared with other account types based on applicable advantages or disadvantages. A TFSA offers tax free growth, tax free withdrawals and considerable flexibility, while an RRSP provides an income tax deduction and tax deferred growth, which can be particularly valuable to someone in a higher tax bracket. The FHSA can make sense for a beneficiary who plans on purchasing a first home, as having both tax deductible contributions and qualifying tax free withdrawals are very advantageous. A RESP may make sense when the beneficiary plans to attend post-secondary education, as it offers tax sheltered investment growth and access to government grants and bonds. A non-registered account offers greater withdrawal flexibility and may provide preferential tax treatment for eligible Canadian dividends and capital gains. Meanwhile, the RDSP offers tax sheltered investment growth, tax free withdrawals of the portion representing contributions, and protection of assets when determining eligibility for provincial and territorial disability assistance programs.
The most appropriate account to make contributions may depend on the beneficiary’s circumstances. Someone with a high marginal tax rate may benefit more from an RRSP or FHSA deduction, while someone with unused TFSA contribution room who is not concerned about disability support asset limits may prefer the tax free growth and flexibility of a TFSA. An unmatched RDSP contribution may also be more attractive to someone who has already maximized their TFSA and receives little benefit from an RRSP or FHSA deduction, but still wants to take advantage of tax sheltered investment growth. The combination of tax sheltered investment growth and protection from disability assistance asset limits may make continued RDSP contributions worthwhile, even without additional government grants.