RDSP or RRSP? A simple example

An interesting forum post from a user in their 50s asked which type of registered account they should invest in.  Would it be better to open a Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP) or a Registered Disability Savings Plan (RDSP)?  The person qualified for the Disability Tax Credit (DTC) and was currently out of the workforce.  No other details were provided. 

Without more information in regards to finances or income sources, others were left to speculate.  Given the circumstances, it might make sense to move away from income tax reduction and towards long-term asset protection to ensure retirement savings doesn’t disqualify them from government benefits. 

Both accounts have tax deferred growth

For many Canadians, RRSPs may be the biggest part of their retirement strategy.  Contributions into an RRSP are tax deductible, and money inside the account is tax deferred. However, without an income tax deductions provide no benefit because there may be little or no taxable income to offset (deductions can be carried forward, however).

Similarly, the RDSP is designed to help individuals with disabilities save for their long term financial security, offering free grants and bonds from the government. However, government grants and bonds are only paid on contributions made on or before December 31 of the calendar year the beneficiary turns 49, so the individual in this example is not eligible. Further, unlike the RRSP, the RDSP does not have tax deductions on contributions.

Contributions into the RDSP are withdrawn tax free

While the full amount of an RRSP or RRIF withdrawal is taxable as income, contributions into an RDSP are not taxed when withdrawn. As a result, an RDSP should not be viewed as a tax deferred account in the same fashion as the RRSP or RRIF. When money is withdrawn from an RDSP, the portion that comes from contributions is tax free. The portion including government grants/bonds, investment growth and eligible rollovers is taxable income to the beneficiary. An RDSP withdrawal can therefore have a lower tax impact than an equivalent withdrawal from an RRSP or RRIF.

Shielding assets to qualify for provincial disability benefits

Provincial disability programs have strict asset limits, and the RRSP is not always considered an exempt asset depending on the province or territory (there are partial exemptions in Quebec and New Brunswick as of 2026).  It may make sense for the forum poster to prefer an RDSP account as it is considered an exempt asset in all provinces and territories as of 2026.

Protection from federal benefit clawbacks

One of the more generous features of the RDSP is that any withdrawals (LDAP or DAP) does not count as income with respect to federal programs such as Old Age Security (OAS), Guaranteed Income Supplement (GIS), Canada Disability Benefit (CDB), Canada Groceries and Essentials Benefit (CGEB) & Canada Child Benefit (CCB).  By contrast, payments from a RRSP or Registered Retirement Income Fund (RRIF) do count as income for calculating federal benefits and can result in support payments being clawed back if income surpasses certain thresholds.

Possible avoidance of withholding taxes

RDSP issuers generally do not withhold income tax at source until the taxable portion of annual RDSP payments exceeds the combined Basic Personal Amount (BPA) and Disability Amount (DA), provided the beneficiary is eligible to claim the DA.  In 2026, a beneficiary could receive roughly $26,793 in taxable RDSP payment before the bank would begin to withhold money.  Conversely, any RRIF withdrawals that exceed the annual minimum amount as per the RRIF formula are subject to immediate withholding which can create liquidity issues for someone with low income.  

Federal withholding taxes on RRIF withdrawals

Withdrawal amount above the annual minimum% Federal tax withheld
Provinces/territories except QCQC
$0 to $5,00010%5%
$5,001 to $15,00020%10%
Greater than $15,00030%15%

Fun with math – RDSP vs RRIF

As an example, consider a 65 year old beneficiary with $360,000 in savings at the beginning of 2026. They need to withdraw exactly $20,000 from their respective retirement account to pay for home accessibility upgrades.

Case A – The RDSP

The LDAP formula would determine that the withdrawal is:

  • 360,000 / (80+3-65) ​​= $20,000

An RDSP withdrawal can consist of both taxable and tax free amounts. The portion representing personal contributions is withdrawn tax free, while the portion representing government grants/bonds, investment income, and eligible rollovers is taxable income to the beneficiary. Therefore, only the taxable portion of the $20,000 withdrawal is relevant when determining whether withholding tax applies.

Even if the entire $20,000 withdrawal were taxable, it would still be below the 2026 combined federal non-refundable tax credits (BPA + DA) of $26,793. Therefore, no tax would be withheld at source in this example, and the full withdrawal amount would be available immediately to pay for home renovations.

  • Gross withdrawal: $20,000
  • Withholding Tax: $0

Net cash in hand: $20,000 (The full amount is available immediately)

Case B – The RRIF

According to federal guidelines, a minimum of 4% of the RRIF should be withdrawn at age 65.

  • 360,000 × 4% = $14,400

Which would fall short of the $20,000 required funding to pay for home repairs. To get that extra $5,600 in cash, the account holder must request an excess withdrawal. By law, financial institutions must withhold tax on any amount taken above the RRIF minimum, and because the extra $5,600 falls into the $5,001-$15,000 tax bracket, it triggers a 20% withholding tax at source. So to net $5,600, a gross amount of $7,000 must be withdrawn from the RRIF.

  • Gross withdrawal (no withholding tax): $14,400
  • Additional cash needed: $5,600

Withholding taxes on excess: To receive a net amount of $5,600 after a 20% withholding tax at source, the financial institution must process a gross excess withdrawal of $7,000

  • Gross withdrawal: $21,400 ($14,400 minimum + $7,000 excess)
  • Withholding tax: $1,400 (20% of the $7,000 excess)

Net cash in hand: $20,000

From a liquidity perspective, the RDSP may provide an advantage in this example because no tax is withheld at source. The RRIF holder was required to withdrawal an extra $1,400 to make up for withholding taxes. While it is true the RRIF account holder may receive a tax refund in the following year, that would not help pay for necessary renovations to the house today. 

Leave a Comment