Investments inside the RDSP – Thoughts and considerations

The Registered Disability Savings Plan (RDSP) is a powerful long term savings plan for Canadians with disabilities, offering generous government grants and bonds, tax deferred investment growth, and exemptions from asset limits with respect to provincial or territorial disability support programs. While investment options available to the RDSP may be similar to other accounts, the plan has unique rules which may influence how funds should be invested.  Potential repayment of government grants and bonds if money is withdrawn early, restrictions on withdrawals, risk tolerance, time horizon and the financial consequences of living with a disability a should be considered when making investment decisions. 

Withdrawals must start by age 60

Unlike a Tax Free Savings Account (TFSA) that allows account holders to withdraw funds whenever they choose, or a Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP) which must be converted into a Registered Retirement Income Fund (RRIF) by age 71 and begin mandatory withdrawals by age 72, an RDSP must begin LDAP payments no later than the end of the year the beneficiary turns 60. Conventional financial advice would typically recommend transitioning into lower risk investments, otherwise known as “de-risking,” as the age retirement or the age of required payments from the account nears. Because of the mandatory earlier start date of the RDSP, account holders may have to consider the transition from higher risk assets into lower risk assets earlier than in a Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP) or Registered Retirement Income Fund (RRIF). Failing to appropriately measure risk could result in the beneficiary beginning their mandatory lifetime payments during a market bottom, forcing the sale of assets at low valuations and ultimately exhausting the portfolio much faster than anticipated. This is also known as sequence of returns risk.

The RDSP is generous but lacks flexibility

Government grants and bonds make the RDSP a powerful long term savings tool for Canadians with disabilities.  Eligible beneficiaries can receive grants that match contributions, while lower income beneficiaries may also qualify for bonds without having to make any contributions. However, the inflexibility of withdrawals because the 3 for 1 proportional repayment rule can make the account unsuitable for shorter term needs or for emergency funds.  This was evident in the 2025 ESDC report where 15 out of 37 respondents suggested that an account type other than the RDSP may be better suited for a person with a disability, with 12 out of 15 noting that the costly withdrawal penalties made other account options more appropriate.   

Research shows that living with a disability can result in additional out of pocket expenses compared to with living without a disability. Unfortunately this “disability penalty” may increase the likelihood that a beneficiary would need to access savings to pay for disability related expenses. An early withdrawal from the RDSP can result in having to repay government grants and bonds as per the 10 year proportional repayment rule.

Example – If the stock market declines, an RDSP invested in 100% equities would likely lose value. If an emergency necessitates a withdrawal during that bear market, the government does not wait for the market to recover to claim the $3 for $1 proportional repayment. The account holder may need to liquidate additional investments to fund both the withdrawal and the repayment to the government. And if/when the overall market does eventually recover, the account holder does not get to appreciate the full recovery because those investments have been sold.

The Primarily Government Assisted Plan has withdrawal limits

Even when the Assistance Holdback Amount (AHA) is zero and the 10 year proportional repayment rule is no longer applicable, withdrawals from a Primarily Government Assisted Plan (PGAP) are subject to strict annual limits which restricts how much money can be withdrawn from the RDSP each year.  An RDSP is classified as a PGAP when the total government grants and bonds paid into the account are greater than the total private contributions.  For typical RDSP beneficiaries who contribute a lifetime total of $30,000 and receive grants and bonds totalling $90,000, the RDSP would be a PGAP and have an annual withdrawal limit of either the result of the LDAP formula or 10% of the fair market value of the account at the beginning of the year, whichever is greater. 

Example – Consider a 60 year old RDSP beneficiary whose account is classified as a PGAP. The RDSP has a fair market value of $200,000, consisting of $30,000 in contributions, $90,000 in government grants and bonds, and $80,000 in investment growth.  The maximum annual withdrawal is the greater of the LDAP formula result of $8,695.65 or 10% of the RDSP’s fair market value, which is $20,000. This means the beneficiary can only withdraw a maximum of $20,000 during the year.  If the beneficiary needed $25,000 (for example) to purchase a disability related item, they could not withdraw that amount from the RDSP in a single calendar year.

Conventional risk tolerance questionnaires may insufficient or incomplete

What risk tolerance questionnaires get right is quickly determining risk preference and time horizon, and then ultimately deciding which investments may be appropriate for the client.  What they may neglect to consider is the uniqueness of living with a disability.  The reduced human capital, which is an individual’s ability to perform labour and generate economic value, the higher out of pocket disability related expenses which may increase significantly as the beneficiary ages, the need for liquidity to pay for a potential emergency, and health, family history, and longevity considerations.  Furthermore, a disabled individual who is a recipient of provincial or territorial disability income supports must comply with the rules regarding assets and income limits to maintain eligibility.

Time horizon

Time horizon is the total length of time an investor expects to hold the assets before withdrawing.  Determining time horizon is crucial to selecting an appropriate asset allocation that realizes the beneficiary’s future financial needs. However, the RDSP has restrictions including mandatory payments beginning no later than age 60, a 10 year proportional repayment rule that discourages early withdrawals, and annual withdrawal limits for PGAP account.  Do these factors change how time horizon, liquidity needs and risk tolerance should be considered when making investment decisions?

Leave a Comment