Owning vs renting a home – The Henson Trust edition

When a parent is planning for the future after they pass away, one of the more important considerations is deciding where their disabled child will reside.  For some families, the goal may be to provide the child with a permanent home.  For others, renting may provide greater flexibility while providing more money to spend on the child’s other needs.  The right choice will depend largely on the amount of money and the availability of suitable housing.  Should the parents provide the beneficiary with a home, or provide them with the financial resources to rent a home?  

Home ownership

Owning a home can provide stability, particularly when the child is able to remain in the familiar family home.  The child is not dependent on a landlord and will have a permanent place to reside once the parents pass away.

The downside is that home ownership comes with ongoing costs.  Property taxes, utilities, insurance, maintenance and repairs can be expensive especially for a beneficiary on a fixed or minimal income. These expenses will increase with inflation, so the parent will need to consider whether sufficient funds will be available to maintain the house throughout the beneficiary’s lifetime.

Renting

Renting can provide more financial flexibility because the beneficiary does not have to pay property taxes, maintenance costs, etc;  If the child’s needs change, it may be easier to relocate them to a different type of accommodation.  However, there are disadvantages to renting as the tenant will generally have less control over the property.  Most landlords have restrictions regarding making renovations to improve safety or accessibility of the dwelling.  There may be limited parking if the beneficiary requires outside help to the rental property to maintain a standard of living (caregivers, social workers, etc).   Rent prices can also increase over time, and a landlord has rights to legally evict tenants in certain circumstances creating a lack of stability. 

Does the decision change inside a Henson Trust?

Rather than transferring ownership of the home directly to the beneficiary, a Henson Trust can own a home for the benefit of the beneficiary without it belonging to the beneficiary.  This can provide the beneficiary with the advantages of home ownership while potentially avoiding some of the legal issues from owning the home directly.  A Henson Trust is not considered an asset belonging to the beneficiary, so it won’t affect eligibility for continued provincial disability income support depending on province or territory.  When the Henson Trust owns the home, it gives the trustee considerably more control over what happens to the property.

In a Henson Trust, the trustee can make unfettered financial decisions based on the terms of the trust, the resources available inside the trust and the beneficiary’s needs.  A trustee may determine that home ownership is not appropriate and instead decide to invest the trust’s assets while using those funds to pay the beneficiary’s rent.  This approach may be more suitable when the trust has limited resources, as the ongoing costs of home ownership can be increasingly expensive during periods of high inflation.  Renting can also give the trustee greater flexibility to adapt the beneficiary’s accommodations as their needs change over time.

For situations where the trust does not yet own a home but does have the purchasing power to be able to afford one, the trustee may again have absolute discretion into financial decisions including whether to own or rent as per the terms of the trust.  The trustee may choose to rent while the beneficiary’s needs are still being assessed and consider owning in the future.  This approach may be appropriate when the beneficiary is young, or when their long term needs are uncertain.

What is the goal of the Henson Trust?

Is the goal of the trust to provide housing security for the beneficiary for the duration of their life?  Or to maximize their financial resources?  A home can represent a significant allocation of capital depending on the size of the trust.  The trustee should consider the opportunity cost of using a large portion of trust assets for home ownership rather than having those funds invested and using the trust’s resources to pay rent and other expenses.  What are the long term implications of using a large portion of the trust’s capital to provide stable housing compared with renting and using the remaining funds to enhance the beneficiary’s quality of life?

What happens if the beneficiary’s needs change?

If the beneficiary’s needs change and different accommodations are required, a home owned by the Henson Trust can still provide flexibility.  Because the property is owned by the trust rather than directly by the beneficiary, the sale proceeds remain inside the trust.  The trustees can sell the home and use the money to purchase another suitable home or choose instead to rent and reinvest the remaining funds inside the trust to continue to provide financially for the beneficiary. Note that buying and selling a home is expensive and can include realtor commissions, legal fees, land transfer taxes, and moving fees.

Sustainability

Can the trust afford the ongoing costs of the property ownership for the beneficiary’s lifetime?  The trustee must consider expenses such as property taxes, insurance, utilities, maintenance, and repairs.  The trust may also need to finance transportation, personal items, caregivers, medical equipment and other expenses to improve the beneficiary’s quality of life. Can the trust afford to own and maintain the home throughout the beneficiary’s life while continuing to meet other financial needs?

Liquidity

One of the disadvantages of purchasing a home is the potential of a large concentration of the trust’s capital becoming tied up in an illiquid asset.  Although the home may represent substantial wealth on paper, that wealth cannot always be used to pay for unexpected expenses without selling or borrowing against the property, which can be another challenge.  More money allocated to diversified investments may provide the trustee with greater flexibility to respond to the beneficiary’s changing needs and the trust’s other financial obligations.

The 21 year rule?

Under Canadian tax law, a Henson Trust is subject to the 21 year deemed disposition rule. Every 21 years, all trust assets are deemed to have been sold and reacquired at their fair market value (FMV). If the trust owns a home that has appreciated significantly, the deemed disposition can trigger a substantial capital gain creating a liquidity issue if the trust lacks the funds to pay the tax bill.  

However, a home owned by the Henson Trust may qualify for the Principal Residence Exemption (PRE) which can shelter capital gains if the trust meets all eligibility requirements. The rules that determine whether a trust can claim the PRE are complex and can change over time.  Families should understand tax implications of having a home inside a Henson Trust and consult professionals for advice before making decisions.

Accessibility

An owned home can be customized to meet the beneficiary’s disability related needs.  This includes wider doorways, accessible bathrooms, ramps, elevators, adapted kitchens and other modifications to make the home more accessible.  The ability to make these changes without asking a landlord for permission can be a significant advantage of home ownership.  A home also may also provide more space for support workers, caregivers, medical equipment, and accessible transportation.

Administration is time consuming

Home ownership also increases the administrative responsibilities of the trustee as they must coordinate maintenance, repairs and other home related responsibilities. The parents must consider whether the trustee has the time and commitment to manage these obligations or whether a professional trustee should be considered. 

Own vs rent, which is better?

What is the most sustainable way for the trust to provide appropriate housing for the beneficiary over their lifetime?

Owning a home through the Henson Trust may make sense when:

  • Stable long term housing is a priority
  • The beneficiary requires or may require accessibility modifications to a home
  • Appropriate rental housing is difficult to find
  • The trust is large enough to maintain the property without exhausting resources
  • The trustee requires control over the beneficiary’s housing situation
  • Maintaining a permanent residence is more important than maximizing investment liquidity

Renting may make more sense when:

  • The beneficiary’s future housing needs are uncertain
  • Flexibility is more important than stability
  • Suitable rental options are available
  • The trust has fewer assets available
  • The ongoing costs of home ownership would put too much financial pressure on the trust
  • The trustee believes the trust’s capital can be used more effectively to maintain or improve the beneficiary’s qualify of life

Leave a Comment